Jesus – The thin line between glory and the end of a cycle

Posted: April 3, 2012 in World of Football

The year was 2009, another season was over and Jorge Jesus was then the coach of an emerging SC Braga. The attractive football played by his team together with interesting UEFA and league campaigns made him bounce deservedly into the spotlight. He was the chosen one to fill the challenging role of Benfica’s Boss. Benfiquistas were embittered and sad, the team wasn’t practicing good football for ages and their big rivals were dominating the Portuguese football panorama at pleasure. From 1990 onwards, Benfica had won only 3 Championships against the 14 titles of FC Porto. In the eyes of Benfica’s fans only a Prophet – Jesus – would be able to reverse this scenario.

The impact was immediate, in his presentation unabashedly proclaimed – “With me, this team will play twice better” – and few games were enough to realize that he would be able to transform a dull and monotonous team into a machine of attacking football.


The season was near perfect and the Prophet’s harbinger was fulfilled. A clear evolution was evident in comparison with the latest campaigns, since the competition is composed by 16 teams.


This year wouldn’t run so well, the team lost some key players – Di Maria, Ramires and later David Luiz – and the André Villas Boas’ Porto was literally unbeatable. Despite establishing a historical record of 16 straight victories and the extension of his contract until 2013, Jesus began to be contested by the demanding Encarnados fans, who were unhappy with the early elimination in Champions League, with the defeat in the semi-finals of UEFA League against Braga and with the 2nd place in Portuguese league, 21 points behind a FC Porto team which lost only six points throughout the competition.


The early phase of the current season was light work for Benfica, the team was playing brilliantly and seemed to be the strongest of Jesus’ era, arriving into middle of February undefeated both in Champions and National league.

The team was leading the league with a comfortable advantage of 5 points, had been first in the group where the United fell and was in the semi-finals of league cup. The black mark on this path was the elimination of Portuguese Cup against Marítimo.

But here would begin the critical phase of the season. On this date, the first leg of the Champions League knock-out stage was disputed in Russia, under extremely adverse conditions, with temperatures around -15 °C, against a vigorous, organized and aggressive team. Besides, was about to enter in the last third of the league, where would face the main opponents in the race for the title. In the midst of all this, there was a difficult match against FC Porto for the semis of league cup. The real test to the coach’s ability to manage physically and mentally his squad had come and the results would demonstrate the true strength and depth of the team.

In sum, the team broke down. Lost the league lead and was eliminated from the continental competition. Above all, the weaknesses of this squad were exposed, the same side which looked unstoppable at certain point of season. There are already some protesters calling into question the work of Jesus once again.

But which is the real reason for this drop of quality?

I could enumerate several that make sense – the fixtures congestion, injuries, poor management, questionable options, strong opponents – but in my opinion the greatest sin of Jesus was the season planning.

He built a theoretically good squad to play in 4-4-2, but in most of the campaign, especially in highly competitive matches, has played in 4-2-3-1. This causes excess of players in certain positions and lack in others. Right now, Benfica has 4 midfielders to 3 positions. Let’s see:

This strategic adaptation arises in the need to make Witsel and Aimar compatible in the same 11 due to the huge quality of both. Yet, Jesus never felt the need to rebalance the squad. To make the situation worse, in January allowed the loan of Ruben Amorim to Braga, a versatile player who would be crucial in the rotations at this point, like in past seasons. Relinquish a guy able to make several positions was a blunder that denotes lack of vision. Another error was the loan of Carlos Martins to Granada at the beginning of the season. He would fit like a glove in this system, alternating with Aimar and Witsel. Jesus, more than anyone, must be regretting those choices nowadays.

The result of all this stands out, Maxi Pereira, Witsel and Javi Garcia are fundamental, don’t get rest and cannot be injured or suspended, Matic doesn’t satisfy the requirements to balance defensively the team alone, Saviola doesn’t play, Aimar rotates with Rodrigo or Nelson Oliveira, who should be near the opposite area instead of receiving ball in midfield, trying to connect sectors. I believe these facts are enough to justify the fall.

X-Ray of Jesus

In my opinion, this is the top of the mountain for Jesus, took 20 years to get here. Rose slowly but reached the top of the climb. He trains one of the biggest clubs of his country, a historical of Europe. I believe this is all that he aspired in his life, this is his peak and few can say that were in the position where he stands now. With this, I intend to say, with all due respect, that he wouldn’t fit in the top clubs of the European scenario. I can’t imagine him reinventing himself, adapting to a competition with different characteristics at this point in his career. The truth is that his strengths are many and are well in sight, but the defects are there too, precisely in sight of all who want to see and he doesn’t care much to hide them, probably it’s his enormous ego what complicates the task.


• Has the whole school of football, played in big and small, coached small and big, the man knows much about the game;

• A born leader, authoritarian one, the players accept his decisions without questions.

• Emanates determination, dedication and aggressiveness and makes the team play in his image;

• Offensive-minded coach with a catching football style.


• Hardly modest, incurs too many times in excesses of confidence and doesn’t realize it. The players absorb the message and become careless in some situations;

• His system exposes the team too much, it’s especially permeable by flanks;

• His speech is not gifted, definitely;

• He’s too stubborn. When he’s mistaken, this trait doesn’t allow him to recognize and rectify:

  1. At the beginning of the season he decided that Emerson would be his left back, leaving Capdevila out. The Brazilian is a nullity on the ball, he’s slow and when involved in the game creation process, the attacking move dies there. The Spaniard only plays when Emerson is unavailable and in the few games he was involved always has performed well. I honestly cannot understand the option.
  2. He has a huge propensity to break the team in 2 blocks at the attacking moment, see yourself, he wants the wingers wide open to give width, he wants Maxi making interior penetrations to unbalance the opposing defensive structure and wants Aimar and Witsel appearing near the opposing box, looking for combinations and increase the firepower. This works when the team is inspired and physically fit, several goals arose with this inner move from Maxi. But when things go wrong, the team has little criteria in the definition of the attacking plays and often disrupts. All losses of possession close to the opposing goal, especially in the right side of the pitch, cause enormous problems, as Javi García, the responsible for stopping the opponent counter-attacks, has to double Maxi and occupy the right back and a huge hole is created between the 6 ‘forwards’ and the 4 ‘defenders’. If the intelligent occupation of space is one of the fundamentals in football, this approach is at least very risky.

Overall, Benfica’s trajectory is being positive, reached the quarter-finals of Champions League, it’s a point behind the top spot of the league and will dispute the league cup final, however, only in the end we’ll be able to evaluate the performance of the coach. What remains in history are the titles, everything else is forgotten, so the achievement of the primordial objective will be essential for the continuation of Jorge Jesus at the command of this club, he needs to conquer the Portuguese league title.

With only five rounds to play, there are three teams separated by 2 points at the top of the table. The day 26 promises to be absolutely explosive, with the leader FC Porto visiting the difficult ground of Braga, meanwhile Benfica will play the Derby Lisboeta at Sporting’s home, a team which, despite being off the race, may have a transcendent influence in the definition of the champion, since after the match against Benfica, still has to face Portistas and Guerreiros do Minho.

If Benfica is finally proclaimed champion, Jorge Jesus will fill up his pigeon chest again and become the first coach since the British Jimmy Hagan (1970-1974) to start four consecutive seasons in this role, thereby leaving another personal stamp on the history of the club.

I conclude then, that in this very moment, Jesus is as close to achieve glory as of the end of his line in the leadership of Benfica. Only time will tell.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s